Simple curves on surfaces and an analog of a theorem of Magnus
Elena Kudryavtseva
(
Click here for pdf version )
(joint work with O.~Bogopolski and H.~Zieschang)
\medskip
In~1930 Magnus proved that {\sl if elements $u,v$ of a free
group $\cal F$ have the same normal closures, then $u$ is conjugate to
$v^{\pm1}$}.
We know the following two generalizations of this theorem.
1) In~1961 Greendlinger proved that if two subsets $\cal U$ and $\cal V$
of a free group $\cal F$ satisfy some small cancellation conditions and
have the same normal closures then there is a bijection $\psi\colon\,{\cal U}\rightarrow
\cal V$ such that $u$ is conjugate to
$\psi(u)^{\pm1}$.
2) A group is said to be locally indicable if each of its non-trivial,
finitely generated subgroups admits an epimorphism onto the infinite
cyclic group. Let $\cal A$ and $\cal B$ be two non-trivial locally
indicable groups. In~1989 Edjvet proved that if
$u,v\in {\cal A}\ast \cal B$ are cyclically reduced words each of length
at least two, and if the normal closures of $u$ and $v$ coincide, then $u$
is a conjugate of $v^{\pm1}$.
\smallskip\noindent
{\bf Theorem 1.}~{\sl
Let $S$ be a closed surface and $g,\,h$
non-trivial elements of $\pi_1(S)$
both containing simple closed two-sided curves $\gamma$ and $\chi$, resp.
If $h$ belongs to the normal closure of $g$ then $h$ is conjugate to
$g^\varepsilon$ or to $(gug^{\eta}u^{-1})^\varepsilon$,
$\varepsilon,\eta \in \{1,-1\}$; here $u$ is a homotopy class containing
a simple closed curve $\mu$ which properly intersects $\gamma$ exactly
once.
Moreover, if $h$ is not conjugate to $g^\varepsilon$ then $\eta = 1$ if
$\mu$ is one-sided and $\eta = -1$ elsewise, and $\chi$ is homotopic to
the boundary of a regular neighbourhood of $\gamma\cup\mu$.}
\medskip
A direct consequence is the following analog of the Magnus' theorem.
\smallskip\noindent
{\bf Corollary.}~{\sl
Let $S$ be a closed surface and $g,\,h$ be
non-trivial elements of
$\pi_1(S)$ both containing simple closed two-sided curves. If the normal
closures of $g$ and $h$ coincide then $h$ is conjugate to $g$ or $g^{-1}$.}
\medskip
The proof of Theorem~1 is geometrical and uses coverings, intersection
numbers of curves, and Brouwer's fixed-point theorem. As a corollary we
obtain the following Theorem~2 concerning {\it normal} automorphisms (an
automorphism of a group $\cal G$ is called normal if it maps each normal
subgroup of $\cal G$ into itself).
\smallskip\noindent
{\bf Theorem 2.}~\cite{BKZ}~{\sl
If $S$ is a closed surface different from the torus and the Klein bottle,
then every normal automorphism of $\pi_1(S)$ is an inner automorphism.}
\medskip
Earlier Lubotsky~(1980) and Lue~(1980) proved that every normal
automorphism of a free group of rank at least 2 is an inner automorphism.
In~1996 Neshchadim proved that any normal automorphism of the free product
of two non-trivial groups is an inner automorphism.
Remark that Theorem~1 and Corollary admit some analogs for non-simple
curves satisfying additional assumptions.
|